Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Micro Tip | Ultra-Fine Micro Tip Liquid Eyeliner for Precise Lines, Waterproof Smudge-Proof, Long-Lasting Satin Finish, Cruelty-Free

So far this is the best eyeliner I have used. It goes on smooth and stays put even when crying or sweating, with no eye irritation.

Very fast shipping from this seller. About the product - my eyeliner constantly ran and bled. Embarrassing. I actually started using waterproof mascara as liner by smudging it with a Qtip. Then I found waterproof liner. Duh! I scoured reviews and STILA seemed to have the best results within a price point I felt comfortable with. I use the dark brown. My hair is light blonde so black is too "heavy metal" looking for me. It took time to learn how to get a soft, blended look because it applies in a sharp fine line but it blends beautifully if you choose to wear it that way. Stila waterproof liquid liner stays put under normal circumstances. I would not condemn the product if I cry it off like some reviewers on other sites had. To me, thats not normal wear. I have teared a small amount and it held up for me. Make sure you dont use eye cream under it because I did one day and it made it slide off so im careful that my eye cream isnt along the rim. I recommend the product highly. I wish it lasted a little longer (more product) but its easy to order from various sources. Im so glad that I found this great product. No more frustrating runny eyeliner.

The liner pencil was empty after maybe 10 uses

They used to sell this inside of Sephora, which is where I first experienced using this product. Hands down THE best eyeliner that I've ever used - and I use it daily. Goes on smooth and consistent, is the right shade for me personally. I mean, if you have dark brown hair and eyelashes, this looks far more natural than say... black, unless you are going for that contrast. I prefer a more subtle look ala Korean beauty standard so this one is a must for me. Stays on even after working all day, crying (yup, tested that before, too, lol), sweating, etc. Love this - I think I've ordered it at least 15 times. I like to have one on standby always, so I don't run out.

I don't typically like felt tip liquid liners. I prefer the brush types because they give deeper color, but they take a lot of time and skill to use. I tried Stila liquid liner based on the great reviews I found while searching for an excellent waterproof liquid liner. This eyeliner was definitely wonderful at first. It was easy to apply, had rich color, and was waterproof, yet easy to remove with soap and water at the end of the day. However, I only got 3 good uses out of it before it started drying out. I got another 2 uses, but the color deposit was not even. So I had to use a few tricks to try and fill in spots where the color was barely showing. After day 5, I could barely get the color to come out at all. Mind you, I stored the eyeliner in the recommended fashion, upside down, fully capped. I always shook it vigorously before use. I even tried warming it up by letting the base of the eyeliner pen soak in some hot water. Nothing helped. I ended up having to dip the tip of the pen in some water, blot it, and a bit of the color came out before it stopped again. It was not even enough to finish one eye lid. I'm extremely unhappy with this purchase because this is the most money I've ever spent on eyeliner, and this is the least use I've ever got out of one. I absolutely do not recommend this product until the company fixes the deficiency. It's a huge waste of money.

Quality color pigmentation, with easy application and good tip quality. However it after a couple hours of wear the eyeliner feels sticky on my eyelids (I have hooded eyes) Stick with nyx, save the $!

first thing in the morning I love this eyeliner almost as much as my favorite brown mascara! This eyeliner is an absolute godsend. If anyone has tried to buy brown eyeliner from most stores, even the high-end ones, it never goes well. Whether you use Charlotte Tilbury, Sephora, Walmart, or Target, you know the struggles—they either don’t have it, it's dry within the third day, used up too quickly, has too big of a tip for fine lines, or comes in a jar of liquid eyeliner. This one, however, goes on effortlessly. It stays on all day, it's easy to fix mistakes, and it lasts despite long days, rain, water—you name it. It lasts a long time and it’s never dry. The best part? It doesn’t make your pale skin look sickly. If you were on the fence, I urge you to go for it. This eyeliner is a total game-changer for anyone looking for a reliable brown liner that enhances your natural look without the typical hassles.

Glides on smoothly. Stays on all day, no smudging

Best sex-proof eyeliner ever!

Great product

Not sure if I got a dud, but nothing comes out of this pen… it’s very dry like one that’s already been used and emptied.

Punta fina, ideal para trazos delgados o gruesos si lo vas construyendo. La punta dura bastante, no se seca ni pierde la forma. Me dura alrededor de 3-4 meses de uso diario. No se corre, hasta después de 8-10 hrs se pueden caer unos pedacitos, pero no se ve corrido. No soporta actividad física intensa (guiño, guiño), pero tampoco te deja con ojos de mapache, entonces supongo que está bien. Era mi go-to y le daría 5 estrellas, hasta que descubrí que el de Sephora Collection es MUY similar, por una fracción del precio ($280), que también me ha durado bastante sin secarse ni deformarse.

Eyeliner is dry. No good. Manufacture's defect! Can't use it. I was on holidays and only opened the eyeliner after the allowable date of return. Would the the company replace the eyeliner for me? I'd appreciate that. BTW, my daughter loves the product. That's why I purchased it.