Milk Bar Soft-Bakes Confetti Cookies (Confetti, 8 Pack)

I loved the packaging! Even the shipment box was branded which got me excited to receive. As a fan of Milk Bar and someone that has been to their stores it was exciting to get something from them in Texas! The cookies were yummy and tasted fresh and soft. Great experience!

Finally tried a Milk Bar cookie. It tasted a like the old soft baked processed cookies we would get as a kid at the store. Cheap and chemical. With some slightly crunchy bits of corn flakes. I am guessing these are nothing like the original. Save your money. Friend did not like them either.

I liked these, they’re very soft and sweet but I expected them to be quite sweet based on the flavor. They have a definite birthday cake type flavor, I can’t eat many in one sitting but they’re good for satisfying your sweet tooth.

Bought them based on reputation of the cakes. Inedible.

These are not the same as the real in store Milk Bar cookies. They are decent on their own, without the expectations though. Buttery, soft, and with lots of fun confetti colors mixed in, the cookies are packaged in twos, which is the perfect amount I'd want at one time.

I like them, but I don't love them. I like them well enough to eat them all up, maybe binge them.. but not enough to want to order more. I like that:--they are well packaged. There are two cookies in a mylar pack, 4 packs per box for 8 cookies--they have a soft, gently chewy texture.--definitely has a "birthday cake" taste. This is good or bad depending on your taste buds--fresh; nothing stale about these.--sweet if you like super sweet--pairs extremely well with a bold, dark cup of coffee.--I always bake with butter, so I am pleased to see actual butter listedI don't like:--"birthday cake" flavoring in cookies, ice cream etc can be kind of weird. This has that vanilla and "something else" flavor that I can't quite pin down.. but it is definitely reminiscent of anything that is worded as "birthday cake".--not just a vanilla flavor (see above), not exactly what I would consider a "sugar cookie"-- if they were closer to that in taste, then I would be loving these.--so soft that they nearly fall apart taking out of package. Since I am usually sitting at my desk with a cup of coffee when I eat these, I am not worried about pieces falling apart.--I like sweet foods, I eat all sorts of stuff, and these are pretty much sweet first, then vanilla-esque, with a punch of "birthday cake" flavor.Once I began eating them with a strong, bold, dark cup of coffee I could enjoy them a whole lot more. Definitely won't be my go-to dessert item, which is crazy because I love sweet sweet sugar cookies.

I’m absolutely not a big cookie person and never have been, but I was given these as a gift and got hooked- they’re so damn delicious! The confetti and pancake are the best imo. Yum!

The flavor is such that I ordered two boxes and have not opened the second box. I will eat cookies if they are there but not these. It’s a bad fabrication of Tosi’s recipes. Try the recipes instead. I’m a little bummed I have some out as gifts.