Sigma BeautyMATTE Eyeliner pencil with built in sharpener, smooth & creamy vegan formula, water-proof makeup, Comfortable long wear, Black Wicked.

I saw it on YouTube some makeup artist post good reviews of it ! But as it arrived I cudn’t wait to test it , and alas! Not the best eyeliner for water line , it might be good for black smoky under eye makeup cos of the non smudge quality but surprisingly it wasn’t working on the water line ..???To the fact that waterline is always wet ., in short only if I can post the actual picture of this eyeliner it’s horrible ! The kohl inside has separated from the pencil and every time I sharpens, it comes out of the wooden pencil socket 🤬😡

Easy to use. You can smudge it a bit to borane, or leave it alone. Once it’s dry it stays in place. Best liner I’ve ever used

It goes on very smoothly, the formula is great. What I like is that it's not a traditional pencil, it's a twist thingy so a) it's safer for the eyes b) does not need sharpening. Did not make my eyes watery. Don't know if it's long lasting yet but I'll find out!

Although the pencil is soft and easy to use. I found it bleeds onto the bottom lid a bit too much.

I have not found a better and darker eye liner than this one. I wear contacts on a daily basis, which makes it so hard to find an eye liner that wont come off after a few hours or smudge my contact lenses. This sigma eye liner does the job! It can hold its color with out smudging for hours!

For me I'm not happy with this eyeliner, it does not stay on all day. When I got home from work it was all smooged all round my eyes... it looked a mess. So will not buy again... 😕