Aqualoq Wax Free Toilet Seal Rubber Gasket, Universal Waxless Flexible Toilet Seal Replacement with Toilet Ring, Bolts, Watertight Drain Kit, 3" & 4"

I have had a leaking seal on my toilet for years. We tried everything. I bought this after reading the reviews. Very easy to install and sealed the toilet up tight. One of the best things I have bought on Amazon. Highly recommend!!!

After renovating a 1929 home, the damage from leaking toilets was severe. The plumber introduced this to me and was installed in 3 of 5 bathrooms. Then the basement toilet that already had the wax ring replaced a couple years ago started to leak again and I only noticed because I noticed water in furnace room coming from under the bathroom space, otherwise, there was no indication that there was a leak. So now 4/5 bathrooms have this.Now in a 10 year old home on slab, a funny odor was not going away for couple months in spite of detailed cleaning. Upon removal of the toilet, it was clear that water must have been leaking since the flange and bolts were nearly rusted away. I required the help of professional plumber to fix the flange. This was easy for him to install having never seen this before. So far I have not seen a failure after five installs.I am hopeful and confident that if anything leaks, I will see it and fix it so nothing underneath rots or rusts again, or erodes away for this house. I am planning on replacing for the two remaining toilets just for peace of mind. There was no other indication of failure here other than a subtle odor. I plan to change myself and expect it will not take more than 15 or 20 minutes each if there is no damage. A small tube of silicone will probably fix two toilets. Water damage can get expensive... very expensive.

Update: 10 months later and it's still working.Before fixing my toilet, I watched several instructional videos on youtube. In each case, they had a perfectly standard setup and everything went smoothly. Unfortunately my toilet/plumbing had some significant differences that several other seals couldn't handle.About an inch and a half below the flange in the sewer pipe, there is a gasket that's broken and falling out. None of the videos I watched had this weird setup. The leak there allowed water to soak into the subfloor. The "neck" on the Aqualog seal is exactly what I needed to get the waste past the gasket without having to tear up the floor and replace the pipe at great expense.Unlike other seals with a neck, it fit the pipe without any problems. Others somehow expected a 3 1/4" wide hard plastic neck to fit inside a 3" pipe. Didn't work - not even with soapy water and my full weight pressing down on it.Another problem with other seals was that they weren't soft enough to conform to the bottom of the toilet. Outside of the round lip of the drain hole on the toilet, there is also a rectangular ridge coming off of it. The Aqualog material is very flexible so it fit right up against the irregular surface. The harder material of other seals left a gap.The final problem with other seals is the height. My flange sits about a quarter inch above the floor, which means most thick seals cause the toilet to lift off the floor and wobble. The Aqualog is thin enough that the toilet sits firmly on the floor and is completely stable.It took me 4 tries to find a seal that solved all of these problems. If I ever have a problem with a toilet again, I'm going straight to the Aqualog Seal the first time. It would have saved me money and a lot of time.

Sits a little high, but the extra coverage goes a long way in making sure there are no leaks. Pretty good product, sets up easily. Replaced the whole thing and had a working toilet in 15 minutes.

Floor was a little rotted out under the toilet and was leaking down the main so I repaired that and fit a piece of 3” pvc to bypass between the flange and pipe and so far it’s great

Neat idea, just didn't work for me. It didn't want to lay flat and kept pulling up from the silicone adhesive between it and the tile. Also had difficulty getting a good seal between the toilet and the flange. While it kept water down in the floor, it would weep out around the base of the toilet on top of the floor for me. I think this product would work really slick if the toilet flange was the exact or near height as designed for the product and I may have just had some bad luck.

Did not work for me. Ended up throwing it out because I doubt Amazon wanted it back, so $21 wasted. I got this to correct a broken toilet flange that was also too low due to tiles being added. I added spacers and replacement flange purchased At Home Depot to bring it up to floor level. I put this over the top and found it did not make contact/positive seal with my new toilet. So I took it off and added the black spacer included. I was not pleased with the spacer included because the screw holes did not match those of my Sioux Chief spacers and flange from Home Depot (not sure if this is a Canada/America difference in standards). However, because of unevenness in my replacement flange, I was worried that the toilet would not sit level on top of the added spacer. I decided that a wax or sponge ring would work better to overcome the less-than-perfect levelness. Even if my setup was perfectly level, I just don't understand how a flimsy thin piece of vinyl is supposed to make a positive seal to the toilet--maybe if it had foam under it--but it doesn't. I am really not understanding this solution--I think some kind of flexible or compressible interface is vital, which this does not have. Money wasted for me.

We have changed the seal on our workshop concrete floor toilet so many freaking times. Still leaked. After this install. No leak. Fixed. Beyond impressed!!! We have fought this leak for years.