SUGAR CosmeticsArrested for Overstay Waterproof Eyeliner - 01 I’ll Be Black (Black)

When I ordered this from sugar cosmetics the first time through their actual website I really liked it. I have hooded eyelids and it stayed in place like no other eyeliner I’ve used. I feel like this one off of Amazon isn’t as strong of a hold but maybe I just remember it being stronger hold since I was so surprised compared to other liner I’ve used. I would order it again but off their website. For some reason shipping takes foreverrrr like over a month. The other one I’ve been waiting for for almost two months. Took off a star for smudging and for eternal shipping.

This stuff won't.come.off. Tried removing with oil, micellar water, wet wipes, nothing. This is my new holy Grail for parties and traveling. The tip is fine enough to draw a tightline above and below lashes, or do a thick/thin wing. Heavily pigmented and super black , not like my other eyeliner pens that give you a watery black and have to have the sh*t shaken out of them. Nice thin pencil that fits in my purse, matte look. Used with and without eyelash extensions, looks beautiful either way. Use carefully as it's hard to erase mistakes. Also, it's great for tightline UNDER my lashes, give it a second to dry on the water line as it might transfer to lower eyelids. All in all, perfect eyeline, no regrets. I'm usually sensitive but I've had it on for 2 days (because it won't come off!!) and I haven't experienced any irritation whatsoever. Just stop reading reviews and comparing other eyeliners. I've found my holy Grail and I'm sticking to it.

Super nice packaging. The product looks so cool and matte. Swatches wonderfully. Didn't irritate my eyes at all. Wore it out for 6 hours. Literally so easy to use. Beeter than my YSL faux cold shocking eyeliner because YSL tests on animals. This is literally exactly as good.Not tested on animals either. Love that! All in a great product by an ethical company. Also, looks so good with the rest of my makeup!! No complaints

A little on the shinier side, this is a great eyeliner owing to the felt tip. However, if you have oily eyelids like I do, it will smudge and that's not a good sight!The only eyeliner that has worked great for me till date is the Maybelline colossal one but I wanted a felt tip liner. So to sum up I am disappointed!

I've oily skin and hooded eyes. Finding the best eyeliner which would stay was a challenging task for me. I've tried various brands from NYX and Maybelline to Lakme, but this is the best product I've used. It stays for hours and doesn't smudge easily. The tip is softer than most eyeliners in this range, but the application is super easy. The eyeliner gives a matte finish. The intensity of the colour is one of the best qualities of the product. I'd recommend this product to everyone as it is one of my best buys in cosmetics.