Jesse's Girl Eyeliner Pencil (Treasure Hunt)

I like how it comes with a sharpener. It goes on smooth and WAY easier than any other kind of stick eyeliner I've ever used. Only problem is that the white doesn't show up very well. Which is to be expected.

I originally bought this in a store some time ago, but like so very many things, its the same brand but lower quality. The store bought one went on easily and visibly, and must have been of a softer material. You have to press on this and even then it doesn't go on well and the result is a lot lighter. And I am conservative in my make-up so I am not trying for dark or harsh. This is just not as good as the older one.

It is as advertised a pencil, so many are liquid and I don''t like them but really like this one.l

It had a cap with a built-in sharpener which was nice, but the color was so light it was nearly invisible & my skin is not particularly dark - I am "light" - darker than "fair" but not "medium" even when tan. I ended up tossing it out as it's useless for me.

I’m a redhead (strawberry blonde) and use this brand and color as an eyebrow pencil. This shade matches perfectly. I can’t find it in stores any more so was thrilled to find it online!

First, the built in sharpener on the cap is ingenious. Most importantly, I love that it stays put. It's fairly water and smudge proof. It's a little bit hard to apply as it should be just a little bit softer. Overall, it's so much better than I expected for the price I paid. I would definitely buy this again!

The pencil is just ok. It does not go on easy, which is what I was hoping for. It takes many iterations to get it on to show the navy color. I am rather disappointed. I would not recommend.

I use this a eyebrow pencil, long wearing, great color, natural looking.