GreoerEyeliner, Quick Dry Waterproof Smudge Proof Makeup Eyeliner Pencil Long Lasting, Eye Makeup Tool for Women Girl (Black)

It was quite thick pencil.to thick for me

This product lasts long but it's not waterproof. It smudges very easily.

Very smoky and not heavy looking. Exactly what I wanted. Defo buy again

Expected a bit darker lining. Didn't last all day

Couldn’t wait to try this so the minute it was delivered I was applying it.Firstly the packaging looks so pretty, like a lipstick, but when you wind it up it’s crayon shaped.It’s so creamy and soft to apply, no dragging the skin, you only need one application and it looks great.If you want easy to apply, dark eyeliner, then this is for you.

This came in a lipstick-style applicator but the moment I twisted the base, the whole kohl crayon fell out onto the floor. Instead of going through the rigmarole of returning it, I melted some candle wax into the base and re-attached it (hopefully!). However, I must warn you to be wary if you have carpets because two similarly branded items I purchased a while ago had ended up the same way and one detached 'crayon' went undetected and I ended up with black smudges all over the areas I had inadvertently trodden on. Thankfully I am having laminates put down but imagine having this mess all over your carpets! Best to stick to pencils.

This product went on ok but smudged and made my eyes look black. I tried it a number of times but it always looked awful

I dislike that advertisement that the eyeliner does not smudge or run, it does, I bought it because of it saying non smudge and don't run as the one I already had I was fed up of looking like a panda and this one still makes me look like a panda I'm disappointed