calirayParty Wave Mascara & Eyeliner Gift Set:: Come Hell or High Water Volumizing Tubing Mascara in Black and Surfproof Easy Glider Eye Definer Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil in Black

I have tried so many different mascaras and have very oily eyelids. This product does not smudge but do let it dry. It takes about 20 to 30 seconds to fully dry so just be aware. Once it does though, no smudging occurs even on the hottest day and spending a whole day at Disneyland. The only way it comes off is with makeup wipes. Definitely will buy this product again!On a side note, the eyeliner goes on really nice and smooth but does not stay on all day and does smudge.

This mascara is simply amazing. It coats my lashes and makes them look longer and fuller. Never smudges or flakes at all, wears all day/night beautifully and the amazing part is that it washes off with just water - no mascara remover needed, no tugging and pulling on lashes. This stuff is like magic.

Not waterproof or smudge proof unfortunately. I really wanted to love this product, esp bc the packaging is sustainable and the product is cruelty free. I tested it out on a work day (with the intention to test it surfing this weekend) but it couldn’t even withstand the work day. The mascara smudged above my eyelid and the eyeliner smudged below, creating raccoon eyes. No idea how this could stand up to the ocean :(

Stays on, no black smearing under eyeA little clumpy

Made my eyelashes clumpy. I usually use maybelline sky high mascara which cost under $10 and gives better results. The only benefit to this mascara was that it didn’t smudge when taking it off