NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Always Keepin' It Tight Eyeliner Pencil, Black

Just came upon this review and had to do it. I have used Keeping it Tight for about 2 years now. After trying everything else at a big named cosmetics store, I found this. With a price far lower, (I use a liner everyday) I was buying the other every month. It’s a no smudge pen with the same line every time. This is perfect, It’s even cry proof, so put on a good mascara, and don’t worry!

There was very very little actual product in this stick. I didn’t even use it every day and it was gone in a month. It cracks easily and falls off rendering it unusable. I would not recommend it.

My favorite waterline eye pencil. Creamy with good color and long lasting

Not my favorite product by this company. It's extremely thin and does not apply easily. Its literally like scraping a pencil on your eyeline. Does not last. Would not purchase again. Feels like it's dried out from when I opened it.

Use this eyeliner pencil in brown on my lower waterline. It goes on easily, looks very natural and just makes my eyes look better; not "made up." Perfect for us "aging gracefully" gals!

The tip of this pencil was so small and the product was so hard. I felt like I was stabbing my eye instead of applying make up, did not like and will not buy again.

I like the color of this product, and the fine line it creates. Very long lasting.

This is smaller and does not apply like all other eyeliner product. Definitely disappointed.

Muy util

Me gustó el tono de cafe

Excelente calidad y pigmento