Thrive Causemetics Infinity Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Built In Sharpener & Smudge Tip, Long Lasting, Smudge Proof, Hyaluronic Acid & Shea Butter, Vegan & Cruelty Free, Lizzie (Moss Green Matte)

I actually really LOVE this eyeliner! Believe me, I have tried MANY! (Two of the big name eyeliner brands that I had tried, their liner was too wide, too big. It was impossible to get a nice crisp line. The one, every time I removed it, would leave little dots of it behind, in my eyes, on my face.) This eyeliner goes on SO smoothly, it's a nice fine line, easy to work with too and it stays put. It's very easy to remove and it leaves nothing behind. I'm going to order another color.

Best nontoxic eyeliner. Love this pencil eyeliner for everyday wear. Just got to replace the one I’ve had over a year for safety. Goes on smooth and looks great.

Very nice, goes one easy and when dry, stays where it applied.

I like the way this eyeliner pencil glides on smoothly. It has a smudge tip also. It stays on and doesn't fade away by day's end.

This is the perfect pencil for me now that I have become allergic to most eyeliners. It provides more of a wide, soft line, but I feel that the sharp cat-eye line from liquid eyeliner was more appropriate when I was younger; now I don't want to look "made up." The hoda color goes with everything. The pencil definitely lasts all day above the eye (but not below). A hint for use: once I dialed the pencil out too far, and the tip broke off, wasting some of a fairly expensive product! It's quite soft, which is why it glides on so easily. Now I'm more careful.