COVERGIRL Get In Line Active Eyeliner, Gray All Day, 0.08 Ounce

This is THE eyeliner! I've tried so many different eyeliners over the years and I always come back to this one! The applicator is super easy to control, the eyeliner has a perfect matte finish, and it lasts all day even though I have very watery eyes! It is an amazing price for the quality!

Nice color and easy to apply.

I liked it very much and I will buy it again! I am able to remove it easily with soap and water too.

This is a nice product that applies easily with a soft brush. The only reason I give it a four is because the gray seems to disappear behind my mascara. It’s a little too light.

Do NOT buy this product! I have ordered it several times and it is all dried up and worthless.

Update: based on all the great reviews and me really wanting grey eyeliner, I purchased this eyeliner at the store. IT'S PERFECT!! It's not lumpy or a weird color!! I'm so happy! This eyeliner is so easy to apply, and I'm terrible at liquid liner, and stays put all day. And it doesn't fall off in chunks. I'm very fair and have grey hair, so black and brown liners are too harsh. THIS liner is perfect!! I must have received a really old liner thru Amazon.I ordered the grey and it's the weirdest liner I've ever had. It's the consistency of lumpy liquid paper. When dry, it's a strange whitish-grey color that is just weird. After a while it started falling off in chucks. Maybe I got an old batch.

For years I’ve searched for liquid liner with a skinny brush. Don’t get me started on gel.....they are thick, clumpy and difficult to apply quickly, but they are waterproof. Now the felt tips arrive and I’ve tried many. Either the color is not deep and saturated and the felt tips drag, skip or get dry quickly. They either are too thick to use or too thin and eventually dry. Yay, this Covergirl Get In Line in Ink Black is close to perfect. IT IS NOT WATERPROOF and it did flake slightly. IF IT WAS.... IT WOULD BE PERFECT, as I wear contacts. (After all, nothing is quite perfect but this is very close.) The brush is the perfect size for picking up the liner; either thin or thick. It forms into an excellent point for application. The liquid product is great consistency and the Ink Black is just that. No shine, no glitter just plain good black liner. BUT NOT WATERPROOF fo contacts!Thank you Cover girl for mastering (the almost PERFECT) liquid liner. All other companies take note...this a winner and the cost is beyond excellent.

I ordered this liner primarily for the brush applicator. I got dolled up yesterday for Christmas Day and wow! I love this product. It's so easy to apply because of the brush and the color goes beautifully with my eyes. I hope they don't discontinue it because it's now my favorite and hopefully I have found my forever eye liner. The color is just gorgeous and not too harsh.