Lucky BrandWomen's Emmie Ballet Flat

I love these!!! I had cheap Target flats that I've worn for 2 years and they had holes and worn spots but were so comfy I couldn't give them up. Except I dress business casual and my shoes looked like crap. So I began shopping and couldn't find a reasonably priced, scrunch side flat that was comfy. Tieks were completely out of my budget, but I knew leather would hold up better. As soon as these arrived I slid them on and wore them around the house and I never even got sore spots on the back of my ankles like every other flat I wear. Usually my feet go through an initiation period with flats during which time I have to wear bandaids on my ankle bone but not these!!! I am a 10 and I got a 10 and they fit great, even with my foot being on the wider side. LOVE!!!!!

These shoes arrived on Friday as promised; however these are not Lucky Brand quality. The leather is not soft and the stitching is flawed. The right shoe could literally fit on either your left or right foot. They appear to be seconds or shoes that were made incorrectly in their stock. I want to send back and receive a refund but there was not even an invoice/receipt in the box. Please contact me.

I am about 90% certain that the flats that I got this time are fake. I have gotten these and other Lucky Brand flats before and they have always lasted for at least 6 months to a year before wearing out. The pair I got three weeks ago already has a tear in the leather! And I have been walking less than usual, not more. I have worn this pair of flats maybe ten times. The lining also popped loose and the overall quality of this pair of emmies seems less than I expect from Lucky.I whole heartedly recommend Lucky Brand flats in general, but with Amazons apparent quality control problem, you might be better off getting them straight from Lucky or from Nordstrom.

I have one pair of Emmie flats that I LOVE and wear every day. They are suede and required very little breaking time. Since that pair, I have purchased and returned about 3 additional pairs, and kept one additional pair (velvet) which I hate and could never fully break in. The sizing varies wildly among the colors. I ordered my normal size in my first suede pair, but in the velvet I had to exchange several times until I was a FULL size above normal and expected them to relax a little bit with time. Months later and they are still too short and I avoid wearing them unless I have absolutely no other shoes that match my outfit. This particular pair (travertine silver) I ordered a size up initially and they were still uncomfortable and felt too short. I don't recommend these unless you have the time to go through several iterations of exchanges. One other thing - they do NOT breathe.

I am very happy with my purchase of these shoes. I bought a size 8.5M in the colors Bourbon and Pewter. The Bourbon pair fit great! I usually wear a size 8.5M so I was pleased that I didn't need to break in the Bourbon ones. Unfortunately, the Pewter ones run a little small for me. They hurt the top of my feet, where the elastic part lays. So those will take some time to break in. The bourbon ones are leather and they are a soft supple type of leather. The Pewter ones are made out of man made leather and have a texture to them. The insoles on both colors are very comfortable, there's a soft cushion that these provide which I'm not used to on flats like these. I could wear the Bourbon ones all day without feeling the need to take off my shoes. The Pewter ones need to be stretched out and broken in but I'm sure once they are they'll be just as comfortable as the other ones. I would suggest ordering up a size on the colored shoes that are not leather and your normal size on the ones made from leather. I plan on ordering these again in black and navy.

Definitely size up on these. I normally wear an 8 but have very narrow feet. Previously I bought another pair of these in my normal size and thought they fit until a few hours into the day when I noticed they had been cutting into the back of my heel on one side as if I had a rubber band around my foot. This time around I bought an 8.5 and they are exactly the right length (though a bit too wide for my narrow feet). They are very comfortable and I can wear them all day while walking around with no discomfort. I walk a minimum of 2-3 miles a day so comfort in a flat is a must for me. They look fantastic for the price! The bourbon color is gorgeous, although my pair seemed to have been sitting around for awhile and needed some leather conditioner right out of the box.

The left one in both pics was bought in store for retail price. The right one in both pics is from Amazon. They are both supposed to be size 5.5M in the color American Navy. You can see the clear difference in shape and workmanship— the left one is more structured overall and the four-leaf clover logo was embossed more cleanly on the heel. Two stars for the quality of the fakes on the right for $15 cheaper... they would have been decent as a cheaper alternative if the fit wasn’t so wide.

I wear size 12 in shoes & 13 in boots. Needless to say finding nice shoes that are comfortable & fit well is difficult. However, these 'Lucky brand leather flats are outrageously comfortable made w/ a soft & supple leather. I also own 4 pair of Tieks & my Lucky shoes are the shoes I grab for 1st w/ my 'Tieks' being my 2nd choice. The Lucky brand fit the foot properly. They are very comfortable to wear all day...12 or more hrs. In comparison, the Tieks, though they appear to be well made w/ Italian leather, sits funny at the heel & no way could I wear them for more than a few hrs @ a time. I've tried various silicone & other shoe inserts of various material trying to make the Tieks work out esp considering my $$ investment for 4 pair of Tieks. My Lucky shoes need NO shoe inserts, are a lovely soft leather & available in as many colors/ patterns as the Tieks at a HUGE cost savings. Let's be real...Tieks are waaaay overpriced. I'd challenge the Tieks against the Lucky brand any day. Im a 'Lucky brand convert! The Lucky shoes are true to size.

Fabulous little shoe! Not sure they're real Lucky Brand but love them anyway! Super comfortable, spongy for walking, love the elastication! Great everyday little ballet flat.

Very comfortable! They seem to be really good quality and like they'll last much longer than other flats I've purchased. They're very cute. Fit perfectly - I actually ordered a size up, as I was worried they'd fit small like other stuff on amazon and ended up exchanging for my normal size. The exchange process was very easy.

The shoes come beautifully boxed. The color is rich. I think I might order a half size bigger next time, but they break in nicely. I have worn them quite often and they hold their shape and still look almost like new.

I have a really hard time getting flats to fit me. These are perfect. I love them. Great product!

I really wanted to like these shoes - they are definitely built with quality, but the back heel part is so stiff that it digs into the back of your legs making it so uncomfortable