Brown Cake eye liner. A wet and dry use pressed powder cake eye liner.

I rarely write reviews but felt this warranted one. For years I have used Clinique water resistant cake eyeliner. It is now discontinued so I looked for something like it. I dislike pencils and gels. When I saw this I thought I would try it. I still have the little applicator brush from my last Clinique eyeliner and used it to apply the new liner. I was pretty amazed. Not only did it go on more smoothly than Clinique but it looked more even. After wearing it all day it has not shifted or smudged. No other liner I've used has ever lasted this long, even gels which never looked good on me. Very pleased and it's even alot less expensive than the others.

Didn’t think it would be up to much as it’s so cheap, but it’s really nice. More of a grey/brown, not super pigmented, but you can layer if necessary. Works a lot better with an eyelid primer, but not more than a few hours on bare lids. I can’t get on with liquid, pen or kohl liners so cake eyeliner makes it easier for me to accurately draw a line on lids. Very pleased…

More like an eyeshadow but does work as an eyeliner - I wanted something I could smudge rather than a fixed line and this works well. It comes in a variety of shades too, which is always a bonus and lasts all night. Easy to remove unlike a lot of ordinary eyeliners. I was worried at first as it was so inexpensive, but on the whole a good product and good value for money.Kate M.

Disappointed with colour and application, very grey not black and has to have multiole application for desired black.

It's brilliant!It's so easy to use for winged eyeliner, and it's better than expensive Benefit eyeliner pens or urban decay pencils!So that's a winner.

Applied as wet liner was gone within hours , don’t waste your money ! So disappointed and fed up with false promises

I'm in my late 40s and am finding pencil eyeliners are getting more awkward to apply as the skin around my eyes starts to age. This stuff is amazing! It goes on really smoothly. I love the brown shade too. It's more of a natural ash brown, which is perfect for me, but it's not easy to find decent eyeliners in this colour. And all for less than £4!

Old school eyeliner and it is a good product. You can use dry for a subtle line or wet down for drawing on bold lines. It goes on smooth either way. When I use it wet it dries down quickly, is a bold line and it lasts all day long. I don't know why I've only discovered it now. I've been around the world of eyeliners, pens, pencils, expensive ones, cheap ones. I still use khol to tight line but this is Stargazer is now my go to for lid lining. I've branched out and bought other colours. Ten out of Ten for this product.... Love it.