Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding Cookies Variety Trio, 2 Ounce (Pack of 12), Soft-Baked, Classic Vanilla, Chocolate Chunk, Confetti, Individually Wrapped, 3.0 Count

I recently tried these cookies and they were simply incredible! The texture was spot on - soft and chewy inside with a slightly crispy exterior. The flavor was rich with just the right amount of sweetness to blend with the banana pudding base. The banana pudding definitely makes these taste unique compared to traditional cookies in a more enjoyable way. Each cookie comes individually packaged which keeps them fresh and makes sure I only eat one at a time... definitely worth the price if you appreciate gourmet cookies

I was in New York and stopped at one of the bakeries a couple of times. Red Velvet Cupcake...Yum, Banana Pudding....Yum, Banana Pudding Cookie.....Yum. I even brought some fresh baked Banana Cookies home to my 4 year old son who also loved them. I ordered some online for my son since he enjoyed them so much. He took one bit said YUK! and spit them out! These are definitely not as good as the fresh baked ones. I'm stuck with a 3 pack since you can't return them. The only way I find these cookies tolerable is if you heat them up in the microwave, it makes them better. I would never buy again!!

These have that banana flavor as they are made with banana, which is cool, i really like that. The cookies are individually wrapped. BUT...they still seem kinda stale. That and the fact that they are kind of expensive I'm going to be passing on future purchases. I liked the idea but the freshness and the cost are deal breakers.

As with the previous review, I was super bummed that my delivery came with only the vanilla flavor instead of the variety, so I knocked off a star. I can only rate the vanilla cookie at this time. The cookie smells like a banana cookie once you open the bag, which I love. Both the banana smell and taste is not overpowering at all but definitely the star of the show still. The banana taste keeps the cookie from being too sweet. It does still taste like a "packaged cookie," though not a bad thing. That is to be expected for shelved products. It is a flavorful, soft cookie for what it is and I can only imagine how delicious a fresh baked one would be at their bakery locations. Vanilla is not even my favorite flavor for baked goods, so if it passed the test for me, I am expecting even more out of the other flavors. Unfortunately I don't have them.

The media could not be loaded. Everyone loves Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding and these cookies are close to the same flavor. We each love a different flavor so the variety pack is a great option for us.

Best cookies ever! Gooey and soft and tasted freshly made

I had such high hopes for these cookies.Unlike others, I did receive the variety pack. But they were dry, crumbly and such a strong banana flavor you couldn't taste anything else.Just really disappointing and wished I hadn't taken the chance.

Was excited to try this product and a variety pack at that 🤩🤩🤩. First I will say this, product was soft, fresh and definitely reminiscent of their famous banana pudding in cookie form…. Yummm 😋. Would of luv’d to try the other flavors but my box came with just the one flavor, may have just been a packing opps but just be mindful it may happen no big deal….it’s still great productPro tip: pop them in refrigerator for a few especially if you live in warmer climate or it’s summertime ( still maintains its softness)